Seriously, how is it I've never melted crayons into shapes before???? Audrie was soooooooo excited about this and it was really, really easy. Not joking, really easy.

After the fun of making the Mailbox Valentine's Box, making these crayon valentines was a breeze. We looked for valentines at the store but the stock was pretty picked over. She can't take any kind of food or candy, so that limits the options. We hit Pinterest and found these crayon heart-shaped valentines from The Nerd's Wife.

I bought this heart silicone mold on Amazon for under $10 and it was delivered to my doorstep 2 days later. Gotta love Amazon.

I had no idea how many crayons we'd need to make 20 hearts but we bought a box of 64 thinking that'd surely be enough...and it was. I almost always buy generic brands but in this case, the Target brand was $.03 more (odd) so I went with Crayola.

The first step here involved the box cutter so that had to be done by me. I simply put a slice down the wrapper and most of the crayons came clean. For the wrappers that were apparently super glued on by an over-zealous gluer, soaking in hot water for just a few seconds took the wrapper right off.


We did end up breaking up the crayons a bit more from what's shown in this picture so we could fit more colors in each heart. The goal was to put like colors in each heart but, yeah, that didn't happen. Audrie just threw whatever she wanted in the mold.

Lesson here, you should definitely put the mold on a cookie sheet. Not something I thought about when putting the crayons in the oven, as they were solid. However, taking crayon soup out of the oven in a floppy silicone mold is difficult. Some of our hearts spilled but it was all good. For the second batch, a cookie sheet was used and made things much easier.

Here's what we had after they hardened.

The hearts popped right out of the mold and were ready to go. Next step was to find the cards to attach them to. We could've created our own but I found this template from The Pretty Bee that's super cute so we used it.

We used hot glue to attach the hearts to the cards. The hearts had a lip on the back so before they could be attached to the cards, we had to rub them on a piece of sand paper for a second so the back would touch the card.